Readers’ Corner: AMA Monopoly, Doctors Threatened With Jail

August 3, 2010
Print This Post Print This Post

This week we address questions about the AMA’s monopoly in billing codes, discuss doctors being threatened with jail—and get Trent Lott into the right political party!

AMA Monopoly on Billing Codes

Tom (a physician) writes:

OK, so you want me to not accept Medicare and any insurance to win the point that we need to move towards the ABC billing? While this proposition makes sense to my rebel side, who will pay my bills in the mean time?

This is a misunderstanding. We don’t recommend that you do or do not accept Medicare or insurance. We did, however, note in our article from two weeks ago, on prosecutors threatening physicians with jail sentences, that obscure provisions buried in legislation passed over the last fifteen years make it riskier for integrative doctors to do so.

For more on this, see our response to fellow physician Richard below.

Nancy (another physician) writes:

If the ABC codes are different from the CPT codes and include integrative medicine treatments and evaluations, but the CPT does not, how can the ABC codes be converted to CPT codes without risking inaccurate or fraudulent CPT coding, putting the M.D. integrative medical practitioner (like me) at risk?

When the ABC medical billing code information is translated into the American Medical Association’s CPT Code, this is “supplementary information”. Both the ABC and the CPT information is available. So there is nothing misleading or fraudulent about the translation.

William (another physician) writes:

I will post this on my Twitter page, Facebook and send this to my patients. Thanks for letting me know. I will be adding things like this to my site as well as other things.

Thanks!

Doctors Being Threatened With Jail

Richard (also a physician) writes:

I read with interest your frightening report [on jail time for doctors]. However, you did not outline a solution that can be implemented into Federal and State Legislation. If you have solutions to this crisis, please outline it immediately and publish it on your website, so we can submit comments and express concern to our congressional leaders. It’s an emergency! If we don’t have a healthcare system, you might as well cancel your website.

Thanks for the chance to clarify the approach we were advocating in that article. We see it as a four-step process:

  • An immediate first step is to repeal the language that makes any “unnecessary treatment” billed to the government a matter of fraud. This is much too vague and is interpreted to include integrative treatments as well as truly unnecessary ones.
  • The next step is to repeal the provision that allows insurance companies as well as the government to decide if a treatment is “unnecessary” in the criminal sense of fraud.
  • A third step is to make a clearer distinction in the law between billing error and fraud, since even Medicare staff can’t make sense of the rules.
  • A fourth step would be to exempt doctor protests over government price controls from anti-trust.

If these steps sound like band-aids, they are. What we really need is genuine healthcare reform, but that is too big a subject for here.

Tom (a nurse) writes:

As a RN who cannot bill Medicare, there are many other threats to nurses from HIPAA, including jail time, fines, and a ruined life. This is just one of the many reasons not to go into health care in the first place and I’m working diligently to get out of it altogether.

We should have covered nurses in the article as well. Thanks so much for letting us know.

Correction

Robert writes:

RE: “Trent Lott (D–MS) ”: Retired Senator Trent Lott is probably surprised that he was a Democrat. He always claimed to be a Republican.

Whoops! Sen. Lott was the leader of the Republicans in the Senate.

4 Responses to “Readers’ Corner: AMA Monopoly, Doctors Threatened With Jail”

  1. Brandon says:

    Let me start off by saying I am a complete laymen in regards to this topic, but I am in the process of researching medical billing right now, and I am just curious as to why there is so much government involvement with healthcare? Like Sue said below, who made them GOD? Why can’t healthcare work under the rules of capitalism like everything else? I don’t know if there even is an answer to this question, or if the obvious answer is just there is way to much money potential for the government to stay out of the way, but I am curious to hear your thoughts. Thanks for the great blog.

       0 likes

  2. Donald says:

    YES WE MUST RELENTLESSLY GO AFTER THE ‘ BAD ‘ ONES .
    BUT GRANDMA’S — HANG THEM ALL — SOLUTION MUST BE AVOIDED . Thank you .

       0 likes

  3. Tom (nurse)’s comment is exactly my concern. I’m a retired chiropractor, and this has been in the air for quite some time. Medicare has been on our backs for years with this monopolistic and destructive of the healthcare system bullying. I, too, worry that citizens will awaken someday soon and find themselves without any healthcare system or even disease-care system. The public hasn’t been informed to notice yet, and they are the most at-risk. We as healthcare professionals know enough to care for ourselves.

    Medicare takes its cues from the AMA, that works presumably for doctors’ benefits, but as you notice above, it works AGAINST our best doctors and certainly against alternative/complimentary practitioners. Who made them GOD? Who made Medicare God? Do citizens have any rights to healthcare in the US, or is this another Myanmar? Who made the FDA GOD? None of these add one benefit to this country, cost tax-payers billions of dollars, and untold anxiety and distress over their meddling in what should be a pretty straightforward interaction agreed upon between patient and doctor.

    As a US citizen, I demand the right to the healthcare of my choice without interference from either government or corporations. If I and my healthcare provider make mistakes, it couldn’t be any worse that the mistakes we make in this system minute by minute – most of them from sloppy, bullying misfits who are incompetent and mean-spirited, surely not the material of which healthcare can be made. Rid us, PLEASE!

       0 likes

  4. arnold gries says:

    again, good job !!!

       0 likes

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy:
ANH-USA provides a comment forum for our readers to share their constructive thoughts and criticisms about our newsletter articles and engage in civil debate with other readers. All comments are pre-moderated regardless of author. We never censor comments based on political or ideological point of view. We only remove those comments that are abusive, off-topic, use foul language, include personal attacks, or are otherwise discourteous and uncivil. Please do not post comments in ALL CAPS; on the internet this is considered "shouting."

 characters available

Follow us on...